60+ Easter Egg Fillers For Teens That They’ll Actually Be Excited To Find

This list of Easter egg filler ideas for teens is based on what teens want and love right now.

You see, teens might cringe at the idea of an Easter egg hunt or Easter games, but the second those eggs have something good inside, they are fully in!

The trick is simple. Skip the childish trinkets that used to have them grinning with delight and go for teencentric things that will delight them instead. 

The list works for Easter egg hunts, Easter party games prizes, and also on point Easter gifts for teen boys and girls.

Most of these ideas fit inside standard plastic eggs. For anything slightly bigger, use oversized eggs or get creative with Easter themed gift-wrap!

Quick Buy: Use my Amazon Storefront Easter Egg Fillers For Teens List. 

Fast Tips To Make Teen Easter Egg Hunts A Hit

Pick a theme for your hunt

A quick theme makes it feel more “planned” and less random. Try: self-care eggs, snack eggs, tech eggs, or “cash and gift cards” eggs.

Up the ante!

Teens love a challenge. Add a timer, a points system, or a few clue-based eggs mixed in.

If you want ideas for how to run the hunt, these 7 Easter Egg Hunt Ideas For Teens To Really Get The Party Started! are perfect for giving the whole thing a more “teen party” vibe.

Use a “golden egg” or two

One big prize egg makes every other egg more exciting. It also helps if you’re doing fewer eggs per teen.

Right, now let's get into the weeds of which fillers to go for... 

Beauty And Self Care Easter Egg Fillers

These are easy wins because they’re useful, shareable, and feel a little “treat-y” without being over the top.

• Lip gloss or Lip oil (huge fans of E.L.F Lip Oil in our house!)
• Nail polish (mini bottles are easiest)
• Nail strips or nail stickers
• Cuticle oil pen
• Face mask packet (these Korean hydrating sheet masks fit well folded)
• Under-eye patches (single pair packs)
• Pimple patches (Grace & Stella patches are SO cute)
• Mini hand cream
• Travel-size dry shampoo
• Mini body mist
• Cute colored claw clips
• Scrunchies or hair ties in cute colors
• Mini hair spray bottle
• Small compact mirror
• Sleep mask (works best in jumbo eggs)

Affiliate link ideas to sprinkle naturally in this section:

Tech And Phone Accessories Teens Love

If you want to guarantee excitement, add phone stuff. It’s practical, it feels current, and it works for teen boys and girls.

• Extra-long charging cord (love these cute pastel colored cords)
• Charging cord protector (little sleeves that stop fraying)
• Phone grip
• Mini phone stand
• Earbud case cover
• Screen cleaning wipes
• Pocket-sized screen cleaner spray
• Magnetic cable organizer clip
• Mini power bank (best as a golden egg item)
  
• Phone charm strap

Non Candy Snacks And Drink Boosters

If you want less candy (or just more variety), snacks are the easiest swap. Teens love anything they can eat on the go or trade with siblings.

• Gum packs
• Mints
• Mini jerky sticks
• Trail mix packs
• Protein bites
• Single-serve snack packs (chips, pretzels, popcorn)
• Mini cookie packs
• “Fancy” chocolate squares 
• Hydration packets (electrolyte drink sticks)
• Instant hot chocolate sticks (for cooler climates)
• Instant iced coffee sticks (for older teens)

Trendy Small Stuff Teens Actually Like

This category is where you add the fun. These are the little finds that make teens keep hunting “just one more egg.”

• Aesthetic sticker sheets (laptops, water bottles, phone cases)
• Mini fidget cube
• Mini Rubik’s cube
  
• Car air fresheners (Love this no-nasties Little Pup vanilla scented air freshner)
• Mini flashlight keychain
• Glow bracelets or glow sticks
• Washi tape (for journaling teens)
• Mini notebooks or note pads
• Tiny gel pen
• Lanyard
• Keychain
• Cute socks (jumbo eggs work best)
• Fun shoelaces
• Black face paint stick for sports games

Experience Based Easter Egg Ideas For Teens

If you want eggs that feel “bigger” without filling them with lots of stuff, experience eggs are the move.

These are also perfect for Easter games. You can do a trade-in table where teens swap eggs, or a points system where certain coupons count as bonus points.

• Cash (rolled bills fit best)
• “Gas cash” (even $5 feels exciting)
• Gift card (paper versions fold easily)
• Movie ticket voucher
• Ice cream shop voucher
• Mini golf tokens
• Batting cage tokens
• Bowling voucher
• “Pick the takeout” coupon
• “Choose the movie” coupon
  
• “Car wash on me” coupon
• “Friend hangout approved” coupon

Golden Egg Big Prize Ideas

Hide one or two “golden eggs” with bigger prizes. It instantly makes the hunt more competitive in a fun way.

• $20 bill
• Amazon gift card
• Target gift card
• Sephora gift card
• Ulta gift card
• StarBucks food gift card
• Mini Bluetooth speaker
• Mini phone tripod
• LED room lights
• HydroJug (that's taken over from the StanleyCup and Owala)
• Movie night kit (voucher plus popcorn)

How To Use These Easter Egg Fillers In Teen Party Games

If you’re hosting an Easter get-together, you can turn these fillers into instant party entertainment.

Try one of these easy formats:

• Egg trade game: Everyone starts with 5 eggs and trades for the ones they want most.
• Golden egg challenge: The teen who finds a golden egg also gets to hide the next one.
• Points hunt: Certain egg colors are worth more points, and points can be traded for prizes.

If you want plug-and-play game ideas teens won’t think are lame, you can pair this list with 10 Easter Games For Teens That They Won't Think Are Lame!

Want instant Easter Fun? Grab our Easter Games Bundle. 

Pin It to Save It!