Simple Ideas For An Easter Egg Hunt For Toddlers With Maximum Fun And Giggles

Your toddler's first Easter Egg Hunt is a milestone up there with their first letter to Santa, so here's some ideas on how to make it an eggs-tra special one. 

At this magical age of discovery, even the simplest activities can spark tremendous excitement for toddlers.  

But planning a hunt that's both safe and engaging for wobbly legs and curious fingers requires some thoughtful preparation.

Traditional Easter egg hunts with complex clues and competitive dashing simply don't work for the under-three crowd.

Toddlers need hunts designed specifically for their developmental stage, with age-appropriate challenges and rewards that keep their attention without overwhelming them.

This guide brings together everything you need to create the perfect toddler-friendly Easter egg hunt.

I've put together ideas for different creative hunt formats that match your little one's abilities, plus safe (but exciting!) fillers that will delight without presenting choking hazards or sugar overload.

Whether you're hunting indoors on a rainy spring morning or creating a backyard adventure, these toddler-tested ideas will ensure your little bunny's Easter celebration is filled with those precious giggles and memories you'll treasure for years to come.

Toddler-Friendly Easter Egg Hunt Formats

First up, here's a list of different formats you could use to create a super fun hunt. 

1. The Visible Hunt

Perfect for: First-time hunters (12-24 months)
What you need: Colourful plastic eggs, open space with minimal furniture

The simplest hunt format is often the most successful for the youngest toddlers. Place eggs in plain sight where little ones can easily spot them – on the coffee table, couch cushions, or floor.

The joy comes from the discovery and collection process, not from finding difficult hiding spots.

Setup tip: Use fewer eggs (5-10) for very young toddlers to prevent overwhelm. Increase the number as they grow more confident.

Also read: 89 Clever And Creative Places To Hide Easter Eggs

2. Follow the Bunny Paw Prints

Perfect for: Toddlers 18+ months
What you need: Bunny footprint cutouts, tape, eggs or treats

Create a trail of bunny footprints leading from one egg to the next. This guided hunt helps toddlers understand the concept while adding a magical "Easter Bunny was here" element they'll love. 

Setup tip: Make footprints from coloured paper or use washable paint for temporary indoor prints (if you're feeling brave!).

3. Balloon-Tied Treasures

Perfect for: Toddlers 2+ years
What you need: Helium balloons, string and tape (you sometimes need the tape to make sure the string stays in place), plastic eggs or small treats

Tie helium-filled balloons to Easter eggs or small treats, then place them around your garden or living room.

The floating balloons create an instantly visible and exciting visual that draws toddlers right to the prizes. Plus, they get the added joy of a balloon to keep afterwards!

Setup tip: For outdoor hunts, secure eggs so that the balloons won't fly away, but light enough that little hands can still pick them up.

4. Colour-Matching Hunt

Perfect for: Toddlers 2-3 years
What you need: Coloured baskets or bags, matching coloured eggs

Boost cognitive skills by assigning each child a specific coloured basket and matching eggs. "Find all the blue eggs for your blue basket!"

This simple matching activity adds an educational element while making collection organised and fair.

Setup tip: For multiple toddlers, ensure equal numbers of each colour and hide them at similar difficulty levels.

5. Easter Sensory Bin Hunt

Perfect for: Toddlers who enjoy tactile play
What you need: Large container, filler material (Easter grass, rice, shredded paper), small eggs or prizes

Create a contained hunt experience by hiding small eggs or prizes in a sensory bin.

This mess-minimising approach is perfect for indoor hunts and focuses the activity in one spot – ideal for toddlers with shorter attention spans.

Setup tip: Use coloured rice or rainbow pasta for an extra festive bin that doubles as a sensory play activity after the hunt.

6. Puzzle Piece Hunt

Perfect for: Older toddlers (2.5-3 years)
What you need: Large-piece toddler puzzle, plastic eggs

Place one puzzle piece in each egg. As toddlers find eggs, they collect pieces to complete a simple puzzle.

This adds purpose to the hunt beyond just collecting eggs and extends the activity.

Setup tip: Choose puzzles with 6-12 large pieces for manageable completion.

7. Photo Scavenger Hunt

Perfect for: Verbal toddlers who recognise objects
What you need: Photos of hiding spots, eggs or treats

Show your toddler a picture of where to look next (the bathtub, under the dining table, etc.). This hunt helps develop language as you discuss each location and builds memory skills.

Setup tip: Take photos on your phone for easy viewing, or print simple pictures for toddlers to hold.

Toddler-Safe Easter Egg Fillers

Now let's take a look at some wonderful ideas for fillers that will bring the joy without causing any hazards or sugar overloads. 

Edible Fillers (For Occasional Treats)

• Cheerios or other O-shaped cereals
• Small animal crackers
• Freeze-dried fruit pieces
• Yogurt melts
• Mini graham crackers
• Soft fruit snacks (for older toddlers who can chew well)
• Tiny cookies like Teddy Grahams

Safety tip: Always supervise toddlers with any food items, and be mindful of allergies and choking hazards.

Non-Edible Fillers (Choking-Hazard Free)

• Finger puppets
• Bath toys (ducks, boats)
• Stacking cups
• Chunky crayons
• Play-Doh eggs (homemade or store-bought)
• Toddler-safe figurines (animals, characters)
• Sensory items (textured balls, squishy toys)
  
• Toddler socks
• Hair accessories (for older toddlers)
• Bubbles (small bottles)
• Stickers (larger sizes for safety)
  
• Bath colour tablets
  

Tips To Make Sure Your Hunt Is A Hit

Timing Is Everything

Schedule your hunt during your toddler's happiest time of day, not during normal nap times or when they're hungry. A well-rested, well-fed toddler will enjoy the experience much more.

Less Is More

Toddlers can become overwhelmed easily. Start with just 5-10 eggs for the youngest hunters and no more than 15-20 for older toddlers. The hunt should be fun, not exhausting.

Containment Strategy

Designate a specific hunting area – a single room for very young toddlers or a clearly defined outdoor space for older ones. This prevents wandering and frustration.

Demonstration Helps

Show your toddler how to find and collect eggs by "discovering" the first one together. Many young toddlers need to see the activity modelled before understanding what's expected.

Equal Opportunity

If hosting multiple toddlers, consider giving each child their own hunting zone to prevent tears over competition. Alternatively, have adults nearby to ensure each child finds a similar number of eggs.

Weather Backup Plan

For planned outdoor hunts, always have an indoor alternative ready. Spring weather can be unpredictable, and a rainy day shouldn't ruin the fun.

Basket Assistance

Provide small, lightweight baskets with handles that tiny hands can manage. For the youngest toddlers, an adult might need to hold the basket while they focus on finding and picking up eggs.

Capturing This Milestone Moment

Don't forget to document your toddler's egg-hunting adventure! How about designating a special spot with good lighting for a quick pre-hunt photo of your toddler with their empty basket, followed by a proud "look what I found!" picture afterward. 

For an extra special touch, create a yearly tradition of taking a photo in the same spot or pose to document how your little one grows from year to year.

Your toddler's first Easter egg hunt doesn't need elaborate preparations or Pinterest-perfect decorations.

What matters most is creating a joyful experience that ensures your toddler and their friends have the most fun. 

Before you go, you might also like...

• 10  Easter Games For Teens That They Won't Think Are Lame!
• 12 Tips For Hosting An Easter Party Everyone (Including You) Will Enjoy
• 16 Easter Games For Kids, Perfect For Parties And Family Celebrations
• 14 Unique Easter Egg Hunt Format Ideas For Every Age Group
• 7 Easter Egg Hunt Ideas For Teens To Really Get The Party Started!
• 35 Fun Easter Would You Rather Questions For Kids To Get The Party Started!